Silver or Gold, and Why Nothing Here Is Plated
If there is one thing I would gently steer you away from it is plating, and it has nothing to do with what it costs.
Most gold coloured medical ID is plated. On a piece you take off at night that might never matter. On a piece worn every day for years, it is the difference between an engraving that is still readable and one that is not. So this is what sterling silver and solid 9ct gold actually are, what the marks mean, and how to choose between them.
In short
- Everything I make is sterling silver or solid 9ct gold. Never plated, never gold filled.
- Plating is a thin skin of precious metal over something cheaper. It wears through at the raised edges first, and the engraving goes with it.
- 925 means sterling silver, 92.5 per cent pure silver. Twenty of my twenty three pieces are made in it.
- Gold is hallmarked at an assay office, tested independently of anything I say about it. A maker cannot hallmark their own work, which is the point of it.
- Silver darkens with wear. A polishing cloth and a minute every few weeks sorts it, and keeps the engraving crisp.
- Gold is worth it if you want to put a piece on and never think about it again. Silver is not a compromise, it is simply a different choice.
- Silver takes fourteen working days. Gold can take up to six weeks, because it is slower to work and goes away to be hallmarked.
Why plating fails, and why it matters here more than usual
Plating is a thin layer of precious metal bonded over a cheaper base metal. It looks right in the box and it keeps the price down, which is why so much medical ID is made that way.
The trouble is where it wears. It goes first at the raised edges and the high points, the parts that rub against a sleeve, a desk, a steering wheel, a sink. On a planished piece that means the hammered surface. On an engraved piece it means the lettering, because engraving is cut into the metal and the plating sits over and in it.
So the failure is not cosmetic. The thing that wears away is the thing you bought the piece for. A medical ID is meant to be worn every single day, showered in and slept in, for years, which is precisely the wear that finds the weakness in plated metal.
Solid metal has no layer to wear through. It marks, and silver softens and darkens, but it stays what it is all the way through. In ten years it is thinner and more worn and still exactly the same metal.
Gold filled, which you will also see advertised, is a thicker version of the same idea. Better than plating, though still a layer over something else, so I do not use it either.
What 925 actually means
925 is the mark for sterling silver, and it means the metal is 92.5 per cent pure silver. The remaining 7.5 per cent is other metal, usually copper, and it is there because pure silver is too soft to make anything hard wearing from.
Every piece in the sterling silver collection carries that mark. Twenty of my twenty three designs are made in silver, and there are good reasons for that beyond price. Sterling takes a planished, hammered finish better than almost anything else, and it holds a deep engraving cleanly without the edges breaking up.
Hallmarks, and the thing most people do not know about them
The gold pieces are hallmarked. The piece goes away to an assay office, the metal is tested independently of anything I might tell you about it, and the marks struck into it record what it actually is and who made it.
The part worth knowing is this: a maker cannot hallmark their own work. That is the whole point of the system. It is one of the few claims in jewellery that is not the seller's word for it, which is why it is worth asking about wherever you shop, not only here.
The silver pieces carry the 925 stamp rather than a hallmark. British law only requires silver to be hallmarked above a certain weight, and these sit below it, so they are stamped for the metal instead. The two words get used loosely in this trade and they do not mean quite the same thing.
When gold is worth the difference
Gold costs considerably more and I would not pretend otherwise. Here is when I think it earns it.
If you will wear it every day for decades. Gold does not tarnish. It needs no cloth, no upkeep and no thought. Put it on and forget about it, which for a piece whose whole job is to be worn is not a small thing.
If it is a gift that is meant to last. A gold piece is the sort of thing that gets passed on, where plated jewellery rarely lasts long enough for that.
If you are hard on jewellery. Manual work, sport, a life that marks things. Solid gold takes it.
And when silver is the better call: if you would rather have a shape you love than a metal you love, if you like the brightness of silver, or if you simply would rather not wear something that costs what gold costs. Silver is not the budget option here. It is twenty of my twenty three pieces because it is genuinely the right metal for most of them.
The chain is where it usually gives way
This is the question almost nobody asks, and it is a good one.
Plenty of gold jewellery is sold with the headline piece in solid gold and the chain in something else. The chain is what takes the strain, catches on things and eventually gives way, so it is an odd place to economise.
On the gold ID bracelet the chain is solid 9ct gold as well as the bar. The two gold pendants come on gold curb chains. Worth asking about wherever you shop.
Tarnish, and what to do about it
Silver darkens slowly with wear. That is normal, it happens to all sterling silver, and it is easily reversed.
A soft jewellery polishing cloth, a couple of pounds from any jeweller or supermarket, sorts it in a minute. I do not include one, because you can buy a better one for less than it would cost me to put a cheap one in the box.
Doing that every few weeks matters more on a medical ID than on ordinary jewellery, because what you are really keeping clean is the engraving. Black filled lettering against bright silver is far easier to read in a hurry than black against grey.
Gold does not tarnish and needs none of this.
Why gold can take up to six weeks
Sterling silver takes fourteen working days. Solid 9ct gold can take up to six weeks.
Two reasons. Gold is simply slower to work than silver at the bench. And it goes away to the assay office to be hallmarked and has to come back again, which is time nobody can hurry.
Nothing sits on a shelf waiting to be posted either way, because yours is not made until you order it. If you need a piece for a particular date, do say so and I will tell you honestly whether it is possible. There is more on the bench side of it in the guide on how a medical alert piece is made.
Questions I am often asked
Is 9ct gold real gold?
Yes. 9ct means nine parts gold in twenty four, alloyed with other metals for hardness. It is solid gold throughout, it is hallmarked as gold, and it is harder wearing than higher carats, which suits something worn daily.
Will silver turn my skin green?
Sterling silver does not usually, although skin chemistry varies and some people find any metal marks them. It is the copper in low grade alloys and the base metal under worn plating that most often causes it, neither of which is in what I make.
Can I shower and swim in it?
Yes, in every piece I make, silver and gold alike. A medical ID that comes off at the bathroom door is not doing its job.
Which designs come in gold?
Three: the planished bar pendant, the layered heart pendant and the planished ID bracelet. The rest of the range is sterling silver. If you have your eye on a silver design and wonder whether it could be made in gold, do ask me, as it is always worth checking.
Is a gold piece more likely to be stolen?
It is a fair worry and worth weighing honestly. A gold medical ID looks like gold jewellery. For most people the far bigger risk is not wearing one at all, but if it would stop you putting it on, silver is the better answer.
Does the metal change how readable the engraving is?
Not materially. It is laser cut deep and filled in black in both metals. Black on bright silver has slightly more contrast, which is an argument for keeping silver polished rather than an argument against gold.
A final word
If you take one thing from this, let it be the plating. Whoever you buy from, it is worth asking whether a piece is solid or plated, and worth asking what the chain is. Those two questions tell you most of what you need to know about a piece of medical ID.
Between silver and gold, there is no wrong answer. There is only the piece you will keep on, and the honest difference is that gold asks nothing of you and silver asks a minute with a cloth now and then.
If you are weighing it up, do ring me on 01283 296118, Monday to Thursday, or get in touch. Have a look at the 9ct gold medical alert jewellery and the sterling silver when you are ready, and there is a guide to the types of medical alert jewellery if you are still choosing a shape.
Julia Usher, Medical Alert Jewellery
This page is general information, not medical advice. Always follow the guidance of your own doctor or care team.
Share
